EXAMPLE
Complete the last example and find the failure load, given the previous results σE = 401, σP = 840 MPa.
Inserting these two values into the interaction models and solving for the failure load gives :-
CEGB R6 model - from ( 3) σF = 382 MPa
'circular' model - from ( 4) σF = 362 MPa - conservative as noted.
EXAMPLE
Using the same 20x2 mm long strip, apply the R6 approach to find the critical crack length for a 250 MPa load.
This is the reverse problem to the above - a closed form solution is impossible, so a graphical or trial- and- error approach must be adopted - thus :-
Trial normalised crack size α | 0.1 | 0.2 | 0.3 | 0.4 | 0.5 | 0.6 | 0.63 | 0.7 |
σE = KIc /( Y√(παw)) corresponding to α | 887 | 615 | 486 | 401 | 335 | 279 | 263 | 227 |
σP = Sy ( 1 -α ) corresponding to α | 1260 | 1120 | 980 | 840 | 700 | 560 | 518 | 420 |
σF from ( 3) corresponding to σE and σP | 800 | 578 | 462 | 382 | 320 | 265 | 250 | 214 |
Repeating this for comparison purposes using the more conservative 'circular' model.
Despite this model's equation being simpler than the R6 equation, a closed form solution is impossible and the above table must be repeated using ( 4) rather than ( 3).
Thus at α = 0.6 from the above table using ( 4) σF = 1/√( 1/2792 + 1/5602 ) = 250 MPa
The critical crack size predicted by the 'circular' interaction model is therefore 0.60x20 = 12 mm - not significantly different from the R6 conclusion.